Mastering a Compilation LP

A compilation brings together songs from different bands, mixed in different rooms by different engineers. Mastering is where those mixes become one record: each track keeps its own sound, and the record plays from first song to last without a jarring jump in level or tone. This page covers what that takes, what every band needs to send, and how the formats and prices work.

What does mastering do for a compilation with many bands?

Mastering works on each finished stereo mix. On a compilation the job is to make songs from different sources sit together as one record: consistent level from track to track, tone that doesn't lurch between bands, and the spacing and sequence that make it play as a whole.

Mastering can't turn the bands into one band. A raw demo-room track and a big studio track will still sound like themselves. The goal is that neither one sounds out of place next to the other.

Tell Jack what kind of record it is in your request. A label sampler, a scene document and a tribute record can each call for a different balance between matching the tracks and leaving them alone.

Who should send the files?

One person: whoever is putting the compilation together, usually the label or the compiler. That person collects every band's mix, sets the track order and handles the request. Bands sending files on their own is how a song ends up missing or the wrong version gets mastered.

What does each band need to send?

Every band follows the same spec, whoever mixed it:

  • A stereo-interleaved WAV or AIFF, exported directly from the mix session.
  • The native sample rate and bit depth of that band's session. Bands will arrive at different rates, and that's fine. No upsampling, downsampling, bit-depth conversion or dither unless requested.
  • Peaks around -6 dBFS, nothing clipping, and no normalizing.
  • No MP3s, YouTube rips or other lossy files as the source. If a band only has an MP3 of its track, ask for the original WAV.
  • Usually no limiter, clipper or maximizer on the mix bus. If one is part of a band's approved sound, have them print both versions and say which one they approved.

The file naming rule matters most on a compilation, where every track has a different artist: "Artist Name – 01 – Song Title.wav", with the track order included. The full spec is in the mix prep section of the Technical FAQ.

How do vinyl side lengths affect a compilation LP?

Compilations run long, so time the sides before anyone presses anything. A 12" at 33⅓ RPM is optimal at 16–20 minutes per side, with a 25-minute maximum. Shorter sides allow more level, stronger low end, cleaner highs and more reliable playback.

Sequencing matters too. Outer grooves handle loud, heavy and bright material better; inner grooves are more sensitive to distortion, sibilance and harsh cymbals. Put the loudest and heaviest tracks earlier on each side, avoid ending a long side with the harshest song, and balance the side lengths. If the bands don't fit on one LP, a double LP is an option. Check the timings against the vinyl times chart and send the Side A/B splits and RPM with the files.

Which masters does a compilation need?

Every release format gets its own master, because each medium needs specific treatment and formatting:

  • Vinyl: a Side A WAV file and a Side B WAV file, prepared with attention to side length, level, high-frequency and low-end energy, sequencing and pressing-plant requirements. A vinyl master is never suitable as a streaming master.
  • Streaming: individual WAV files from the approved master, formatted correctly for the intended platform.
  • CD: a DDP image with PQ info, plus ISRC, UPC and CD-Text if provided.
  • Bandcamp/download: high-quality WAV suitable for sale and platform conversion.
  • Cassette: cassette-specific masters when the release needs them.

Although Enormous Door does not press vinyl themselves, we are happy to connect you to Helios Pressing, who can take care of all aspects of the vinyl pressing process for you. See the vinyl pressing page.

How much does it cost to master a compilation LP?

Prices are fixed by total running time. The Full Release Package covers every master for the formats you confirm, which suits a compilation going to vinyl, streaming and more:

  • LP up to 45 minutes: $600 (Single-Format Master $500)
  • LP up to 60 minutes: $700 (Single-Format Master $600)
  • Double LP up to 80 minutes: $800 (Single-Format Master $700)
  • Double LP up to 120 minutes: $900 (Single-Format Master $800)

Beyond Heavy, the collaboration of Jack Control and Maor Appelbaum, is one fixed price per length with all release formats included: $850 for an LP up to 45 minutes, up to $1500 for a double LP up to 120 minutes. It is for release-ready mixes only, so every band's mix has to meet that bar. Fit is confirmed in 24–48 hours. Full details are on the pricing page.

Who has Jack mastered?

Enormous Door Mastering has 5000+ mastering credits since 2008 across metal, punk, hardcore, doom, death metal, black metal and grind. Lead credits include Darkthrone, Mork, Aura Noir and Frozen Soul. RUÏM's Black Royal Spiritism…, mastered by Jack Control, won the Norwegian Spellemann award for Best Metal Album 2023. More credits are on the clients page.

How do I start?

Use the Start Your Project form: say it's a compilation, roughly how long it runs and which formats are involved. You don't need every band's files in hand to ask. Jack replies personally with the right path, a price range, notes on file readiness and the schedule. Every project gets a mastered sample for approval before the final masters, and expected turnaround is usually 2–5 days, depending on client responsiveness and approval.

Putting a compilation together? Start your project.